By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
DailynewsegyptDailynewsegypt
  • Home
  • Business
    BusinessShow More
    Popular video-sharing app TikTok was granted by the U.S. government a 15-day extension to reach a deal with U.S. buyers, a federal court filing showed Friday. This means the deadline for ByteDance, TikTok's Chinese parent company, to reach a deal with Oracle and Walmart has been extended from Nov. 12 to Nov. 27, according to the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia.
    TikTok updates its community guidelines
    March 23, 2023
    IFC to invest in Mediterrania Capital Partners’ fund to support African mid-cap businesses
    IFC to invest in Mediterrania Capital Partners’ fund to support African mid-cap businesses
    March 23, 2023
    Sukari gold mine’s production reaches 5.2 million ounces with $7.5bn revenues in February 2023
    Sukari gold mine’s production reaches 5.2 million ounces with $7.5bn revenues in February 2023
    March 23, 2023
    EFG Hermes records EGP 11bn revenue in FY22
    EFG Hermes records EGP 11bn revenue in FY22
    March 23, 2023
    Egyptian Environment Minister discusses cooperation with WFP representative in Cairo 
    Egyptian Environment Minister discusses cooperation with WFP representative in Cairo 
    March 23, 2023
  • Politics
    PoliticsShow More
    Egypt's Health Minister discuss bilateral cooperation with an Italian delegation 
    Egypt’s Health Minister discuss bilateral cooperation with an Italian delegation 
    March 23, 2023
    Egypt’s foreign minister phones Algerian counterpart over boosting ties
    Egypt’s foreign minister phones Algerian counterpart over boosting ties
    March 22, 2023
    Turkish President  Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and Egypt President Abdel-Fattah Al-Sisi met in Doha
    Opinion| Türkiye and Egypt: For better times with many opportunities
    March 22, 2023
    Drought caused 43,000 deaths in Somalia in 2022: UN
    Drought caused 43,000 deaths in Somalia in 2022: UN 
    March 22, 2023
    Opinion| The Chinese dragon occupies America's place in the Middle East
    Opinion| The Chinese dragon occupies America’s place in the Middle East
    March 22, 2023
  • Interviews
    InterviewsShow More
    Government should help Egyptian arts revive its pioneering role: Omar Abdel Aziz
    Government should help Egyptian arts revive its pioneering role: Omar Abdel Aziz
    March 15, 2023
    Interconnected healthcare systems in Africa require political will from North African leaders: Amref official
    Interconnected healthcare systems in Africa require political will from North African leaders: Amref official
    March 12, 2023
    EGX ready for government’s IPOs programme: Chairperson
    EGX ready for government’s IPOs programme: Chairperson
    February 15, 2023
    British International Investment invests $4.5bn in 700 businesses across Africa: Sherine Shohdy
    February 15, 2023
    Valeo has invested around €0.5bn in Egypt over the past 10 years: CEO
    Valeo has invested around €0.5bn in Egypt over the past 10 years: CEO
    December 27, 2022
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
Reading: Egypt is not Somalia (it isn’t Switzerland, either)
Share
Notification
Latest News
Popular video-sharing app TikTok was granted by the U.S. government a 15-day extension to reach a deal with U.S. buyers, a federal court filing showed Friday. This means the deadline for ByteDance, TikTok's Chinese parent company, to reach a deal with Oracle and Walmart has been extended from Nov. 12 to Nov. 27, according to the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia.
TikTok updates its community guidelines
Business
Strong representation of women in TV series of Ramadan 2023
Strong representation of women in TV series of Ramadan 2023
Culture Cinema
IFC to invest in Mediterrania Capital Partners’ fund to support African mid-cap businesses
IFC to invest in Mediterrania Capital Partners’ fund to support African mid-cap businesses
Business
Sukari gold mine’s production reaches 5.2 million ounces with $7.5bn revenues in February 2023
Sukari gold mine’s production reaches 5.2 million ounces with $7.5bn revenues in February 2023
Business
EFG Hermes records EGP 11bn revenue in FY22
EFG Hermes records EGP 11bn revenue in FY22
Business
Aa
Aa
DailynewsegyptDailynewsegypt
  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
  • Advertise
© 2023 DNE News. All Rights Reserved.
Dailynewsegypt > Blog > Opinion > Egypt is not Somalia (it isn’t Switzerland, either)
Opinion

Egypt is not Somalia (it isn’t Switzerland, either)

H.A. Hellyer
Last updated: 2013/02/05 at 10:31 PM
By H.A. Hellyer 6 Min Read
Share
Hesham Hellyer
Hesham Hellyer
SHARE
Hesham Hellyer
Hesham Hellyer

The last two weeks were not a huge surprise. For some, it seems that the last couple of weeks were the result of a strategy by forces opposed to the presidency of Mohamed Morsi—that the violence was planned, arranged, and implemented. There is a corresponding logic to that line of thought—that had the violence not been planned, it would not have happened.

That is an attractive line of thought, but that narrative does not nearly do justice to the injustice that has been taking place in Egypt over the past two weeks. From the outset, if we are to be accurate, and our analysis is to be useful, the narrative has to begin much earlier than the last two weeks. Indeed, it begins years, if not decades, ago.

In a fully functioning state, the use of legitimate violence is reserved for the state and its delegated institutions. This is the difference between a country like Switzerland, and a country like Somalia.

In one, if a group or individual uses violence, the state intervenes on behalf of the citizenry to declare plainly and clearly that only the state can do so. Where vigilante violence, let alone criminal violence, occurs without challenge, the state has broken down.

It ought to be clear—Egypt is not Somalia. Nevertheless, it is also not Switzerland. In Switzerland, the state’s institutions were not built on the bedrock of fear, as it was during the former regime in Egypt. Rather, the state benefited from respect of the citizenry, where the broad, overwhelming majority of individuals believed that the state’s institutions were their institutions, and not the tools of a coercive elite, designed to impose their will upon everyone else.

In Egypt today, the state’s institutions are different from what they were under Hosni Mubarak. While fear remains, the critical ‘curtain of fear’ has been ripped to shreds. People are still afraid to a large degree—witness, for example, how a man beaten by the state’s police force a few days ago, denied it in court, out of fear. Yet, fear of the state no longer plays the same role it once did.

Many will speak favourably of this—and they are right to do so. Fear is not only an immoral and unethical way to maintain a society, it is an unsustainable one. A strong society is one where citizens feel their rights are protected—from and by each other, as well as from and by the state.

But Egyptians have not yet substituted fear for something else in their state institutions. Respect did not suddenly replace fear in those institutions. Respect did not suddenly become the predominant instinct inside the Ministry of Interior—whether inwardly, among its own officials, or from the citizenry toward its officials.

In the past, Egyptians feared the police—and hence they did as they were told, even while their rights were infringed upon. Today, they do not fear the police to the same degree at all—but they also do not respect the police. That means that there are cracks in the structure of Egypt’s state. These cracks aren’t causing the entire structure to break down and fall into wide-scale anarchy and chaos, but they are serious deficiencies and flaws.

When the state is thus challenged by a crisis or a set of unusual circumstances, it does so from a point of weakness. The real source of a strong state is the respect that the citizenry has towards its institutions. When that respect was almost absent to begin with, having been substituted with fear, it is a weak state indeed.

Imagine, then, when you have a state whose institutions are not feared, nor respected, but actually disrespected, because the institutions invite such disrespect when they do not uphold the rights of the Egyptian citizen, as the Ministry of Interior has done.

You then imagine, quite well, the Egyptian state.

The question becomes, then: Who is responsible for instilling respect in those institutions? The answer can only be: those who are in power. Those in power, who legitimately hold the reins as per the election results, must implement reforms and restructure those parts of the state that can and need to be restructured. There is no-one else who can do that.

If, on the other hand, those in power not only fail to carry out such reforms—but make the problems worse by prioritising their partisan share of the state? They can only be described as having failed their mandate—and in a time of revolution, they can only be described as having failed their mandate exponentially more.

 

Dr H A Hellyer, a non-resident fellow at the Brookings Institution, is a Cairo-based specialist on Arab affairs, and relations between the Muslim world and the west. Fellow at ISPU, he was previously senior practice consultant at Gallup, and senior research fellow at Warwick University. Find him online @hahellyer and www.hahellyer.com .

You Might Also Like

Opinion| Türkiye and Egypt: For better times with many opportunities

Drought caused 43,000 deaths in Somalia in 2022: UN 

Opinion| The Chinese dragon occupies America’s place in the Middle East

Beyond GDP: Changing how we measure progress is key to tackling a world in crisis

IMF reaches staff-level deal with Somalia

TAGGED: DNE, H.A. Hellyer, Morsi, Mubarak, Muslim Brotherhood, opinion, police, Somalia, Switzerland, violence
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print
By H.A. Hellyer
Dr H A Hellyer, a non-resident fellow at the Brookings Institution, is a Cairo-based specialist on Arab affairs, and relations between the Muslim world and the west. Fellow at ISPU, he was previously senior practice consultant at Gallup, and senior research fellow at Warwick University. Find him online @hahellyer and www.hahellyer.com .
Previous Article Six pieces, looking for an author
Next Article Female genital mutilation: A bitter experience
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Ad image

Stay Connected

Facebook Like
Twitter Follow
Instagram Follow
Youtube Subscribe

Latest News

Popular video-sharing app TikTok was granted by the U.S. government a 15-day extension to reach a deal with U.S. buyers, a federal court filing showed Friday. This means the deadline for ByteDance, TikTok's Chinese parent company, to reach a deal with Oracle and Walmart has been extended from Nov. 12 to Nov. 27, according to the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia.
TikTok updates its community guidelines
Business
Strong representation of women in TV series of Ramadan 2023
Strong representation of women in TV series of Ramadan 2023
Culture Cinema
IFC to invest in Mediterrania Capital Partners’ fund to support African mid-cap businesses
IFC to invest in Mediterrania Capital Partners’ fund to support African mid-cap businesses
Business
Sukari gold mine’s production reaches 5.2 million ounces with $7.5bn revenues in February 2023
Sukari gold mine’s production reaches 5.2 million ounces with $7.5bn revenues in February 2023
Business
//
Egypt’s only independent daily newspaper in English. Discuss the country’s latest with the paper’s reporters, editors, and other readers.

Quick Link

  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

© 2023 DNE News. All Rights Reserved.

Join Us!

Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest news, podcasts etc..

Zero spam, Unsubscribe at any time.

Removed from reading list

Undo
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?