By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
DailynewsegyptDailynewsegypt
  • Home
  • Business
    BusinessShow More
    Popular video-sharing app TikTok was granted by the U.S. government a 15-day extension to reach a deal with U.S. buyers, a federal court filing showed Friday. This means the deadline for ByteDance, TikTok's Chinese parent company, to reach a deal with Oracle and Walmart has been extended from Nov. 12 to Nov. 27, according to the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia.
    TikTok updates its community guidelines
    March 23, 2023
    IFC to invest in Mediterrania Capital Partners’ fund to support African mid-cap businesses
    IFC to invest in Mediterrania Capital Partners’ fund to support African mid-cap businesses
    March 23, 2023
    Sukari gold mine’s production reaches 5.2 million ounces with $7.5bn revenues in February 2023
    Sukari gold mine’s production reaches 5.2 million ounces with $7.5bn revenues in February 2023
    March 23, 2023
    EFG Hermes records EGP 11bn revenue in FY22
    EFG Hermes records EGP 11bn revenue in FY22
    March 23, 2023
    Egyptian Environment Minister discusses cooperation with WFP representative in Cairo 
    Egyptian Environment Minister discusses cooperation with WFP representative in Cairo 
    March 23, 2023
  • Politics
    PoliticsShow More
    Egypt's Health Minister discuss bilateral cooperation with an Italian delegation 
    Egypt’s Health Minister discuss bilateral cooperation with an Italian delegation 
    March 23, 2023
    Egypt’s foreign minister phones Algerian counterpart over boosting ties
    Egypt’s foreign minister phones Algerian counterpart over boosting ties
    March 22, 2023
    Turkish President  Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and Egypt President Abdel-Fattah Al-Sisi met in Doha
    Opinion| Türkiye and Egypt: For better times with many opportunities
    March 22, 2023
    Drought caused 43,000 deaths in Somalia in 2022: UN
    Drought caused 43,000 deaths in Somalia in 2022: UN 
    March 22, 2023
    Opinion| The Chinese dragon occupies America's place in the Middle East
    Opinion| The Chinese dragon occupies America’s place in the Middle East
    March 22, 2023
  • Interviews
    InterviewsShow More
    Government should help Egyptian arts revive its pioneering role: Omar Abdel Aziz
    Government should help Egyptian arts revive its pioneering role: Omar Abdel Aziz
    March 15, 2023
    Interconnected healthcare systems in Africa require political will from North African leaders: Amref official
    Interconnected healthcare systems in Africa require political will from North African leaders: Amref official
    March 12, 2023
    EGX ready for government’s IPOs programme: Chairperson
    EGX ready for government’s IPOs programme: Chairperson
    February 15, 2023
    British International Investment invests $4.5bn in 700 businesses across Africa: Sherine Shohdy
    February 15, 2023
    Valeo has invested around €0.5bn in Egypt over the past 10 years: CEO
    Valeo has invested around €0.5bn in Egypt over the past 10 years: CEO
    December 27, 2022
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
Reading: Interviewing extremists: a journalistic dilemma and responsibility
Share
Notification
Latest News
Popular video-sharing app TikTok was granted by the U.S. government a 15-day extension to reach a deal with U.S. buyers, a federal court filing showed Friday. This means the deadline for ByteDance, TikTok's Chinese parent company, to reach a deal with Oracle and Walmart has been extended from Nov. 12 to Nov. 27, according to the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia.
TikTok updates its community guidelines
Business
Strong representation of women in TV series of Ramadan 2023
Strong representation of women in TV series of Ramadan 2023
Culture Cinema
IFC to invest in Mediterrania Capital Partners’ fund to support African mid-cap businesses
IFC to invest in Mediterrania Capital Partners’ fund to support African mid-cap businesses
Business
Sukari gold mine’s production reaches 5.2 million ounces with $7.5bn revenues in February 2023
Sukari gold mine’s production reaches 5.2 million ounces with $7.5bn revenues in February 2023
Business
EFG Hermes records EGP 11bn revenue in FY22
EFG Hermes records EGP 11bn revenue in FY22
Business
Aa
Aa
DailynewsegyptDailynewsegypt
  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
  • Advertise
© 2023 DNE News. All Rights Reserved.
Dailynewsegypt > Blog > Egypt > Interviewing extremists: a journalistic dilemma and responsibility
EgyptIn FocusPolitics

Interviewing extremists: a journalistic dilemma and responsibility

Amira El-Fekki
Last updated: 2017/11/26 at 3:07 PM
By Amira El-Fekki 13 Min Read
Share
SHARE

One of the tools that has served terrorists such as the Islamic State group (IS) is, unfortunately, the media, whether their own platforms or coverage they obtained after each attack.

The former is propaganda, while the second is meant to be documentation. In both cases, the audience is left with horrific images and footage.

Moreover, thousands of messages of hate are conveyed through mainstream media. When the platform is open to religious figures, controversy arises over what should be considered extremist and inciting.

Could we then bear to give those who advocate killing those of different faiths more media space?

In Egypt, a recent debate emerged when, on 16 November, Al-Hayat TV broadcast an exclusive interview by Emad Adeeb with Mohamed Abdel Reheem Al-Mesmari, who was captured by security forces in retaliation operations for Al-Wahat shootout, which claimed the lives of more than a dozen police officers, according to the Ministry of Interior.

Al-Mesmari, a Libyan citizen from Derna, was asked about the circumstances in which he joined extremist groups, the military training he received, and details of Al-Wahat shootout.

But half of the interview questions were about whether he had remorse, slept with a clear conscience, or felt okay about killing people.

When Al-Mesmari put forward a religious argument as justification for his killing he said that “Prophet Mohamed, peace be upon him, killed his own uncles,” Adeeb’s answer to such an allegation was that they were “infidels”, to which Al-Mesmari responded, “exactly”.

There was no further challenge; Adeeb didn’t question the statement – argued by scholars to be incorrect.

The anchor faced criticism. In response, he told state-run newspaper Al-Ahram that the interview was an “exclusive chance which I couldn’t refuse”, that he tried to be as “objective” as possible, and that his profession is about enabling others to express themselves.

However, many – who were not questioning his integrity or professionalism – were, rather, concerned that a person regarded as an extremist and terrorist killer was given a media platform.

Hossam Al-Sokkary, former head of BBC Arabic, wrote in a column for the local Al-Shorouk newspaper last week that Adeeb failed to send a responsible message on terrorism, instead giving a platform for the “terrorist” to send his ideas to millions of people.

Likewise, Al-Akhbar’s journalist Eman Rashed described the interview as a “one-sided dialogue”, opining that an expert on religious teachings should have been present to respond, as well as a psychological analyst to explain why the “blood-thirsty creature” felt no regrets towards murdering innocent people.

Al-Ahram’s Khaled Al-Asmai wrote that there is supposed to be confrontation between the culture of death and demolition and that of life, but instead, the interview resulted in creating supporters for those who have blood on their hands.

Interviewing extremists comes with great responsibility

Journalist Ghada Atef explained that when she pursued a woman who joined IS, she was going to trace her radical transformation. Having background knowledge on her life, Atef wanted to ask her who influenced her or whether an unfortunate event had driven her.

“I was surprised because she was originally an open-minded person and suddenly completely changed. What were her reasons?”

Atef did not eventually reach her subject, but had she interviewed her, she would have aimed to shed light on the “terrorist, not religious” ideology, and would not have run the story as a one-on-one interview, but rather, talked to other sources as well.

As such, Atef argued that Adeeb failed at doing his job when he did not come prepared enough to reply to his interviewee who stated incorrect historical facts, which according to her, only showed how brainwashed he was.

“Had Adeeb challenged him, the core of the extremist ideology the interviewee tried to promote would have fallen to pieces,” she said.

As for journalist Asmaa Nassar, she interviewed members of Islamist groups such as the Muslim Brotherhood and the Salafists back in 2006. She viewed those encounters as journalistically “highly important”, though she also saw Adeeb’s interview as a failure.

Nassar said that at the time, she was observing the rising threat of extremists and wanted to raise awareness on their upcoming violence.

“I asked them about their personal lives, the environment they grew up in, social circumstances they faced. But I also had religious academic knowledge which I used to prevent reflecting their extremism in my articles,” Nassar said.

Yet, despite being able to challenge extremist ideology with religious arguments, some religious dilemmas cannot be solved, according to Nassar.

“Your sense about humanity and culture must be reflected, you must point out to the audience that there are different perspectives, such as highlighting contradictions in the religious texts,” Nassar said.

To her, Adeeb did not go deep enough when interviewing his subject, thus misapplying balance.

Impact on audience taken into consideration

Such concerns have already been tackled by journalists and experts worldwide.

In an article for the Guardian in November 2016, BBC presenter Samira Ahmed wrote that news editors might underestimate “the distress of hearing certain views expressed on air, especially if these are not challenged properly.”

“When I first reported on the rise of antisemitic and misogynistic Islamic radicals on Newsnight in 1994, our film didn’t simply put a leader on TV. We interviewed them, but also their critics, including other Muslim students,” Ahmed wrote – also pointing out to the same dangers of giving a platform to far-right racism.

Anjem Choudary, convicted for supporting IS, is an illustrating example of how radicals were given platforms to preach pro-terrorist messages in the media. He has several interviews available on YouTube.

CBS’ Clarissa Ward also interviewed Choudary on 60 Minutes, who was described by her producer as a “steamroller, trying to dominate the discussion and refusing to answer Ward’s questions.”

When Sun News Network host Ezra Levant interviewed Choudary, he faced him with atrocities committed by IS, which he not only falsely denied, but he succeeded in making the conversation about the Western world against Muslims. Choudary called Osama bin Laden a freedom fighter on air.

After the one-on-one interview ended, Levant said less-informed viewers might say ‘oh he’s got some good views’.

Experts have established that extremists will take media opportunities to promote their ideas, defend their right to killing, and attract more people. But journalists must bear in mind the messages they aim to send to viewers through interviewing them.

According to Eman Ragab, expert on regional security at Al-Ahram Center for Political and Strategic Studies, those who have not renounced their extremist ideology will aim at showing capacity and confidence when answering their interviewers’ questions.

“But a debate will show the weakness of their arguments, not only logically, but also factually,” she wrote in a recent op-ed for local website Masrawy.

Development of conversing with extremists, different models presented

Interviewing extremists developed from trying to acquire knowledge on background circumstances, recruitment, activities, and organisation, to focusing on personalities.

Among the most famous interviews with terrorists were those conducted by Al-Jazeera’s former investigative journalist Yousri Fouda, who sat down with 9/11 masterminds before their capture, Ramzi bin al-Shibh and Khalid Sheikh Mohammed.

Fouda’s series provided detailed information on how the plot was conceived, but in his book, In Harm’s Way: From the Strongholds of Al-Qaeda to ISIS Incubators, Fouda outlined how he was summoned to the interview and how they they were in control of the situation the entire time, including the camera, what could be shared, when, and where. “All I had to do was listen,” Fouda wrote, as he awaited the information and documents.

On the other hand, an interview with a supposed IS fighter in Syria published by Deutsche Welle in June 2015 had the following introduction:

“You might argue that one shouldn’t give a terrorist a platform to explain his views. But we wanted to know how a person of our age, with a similar educational background to us, can have such a fundamentally different worldview. We were deliberately open, to try to understand – although we might disagree with the other’s beliefs.”

The interviewers asked if their subject ever had doubts, what his daily life looked like, about his habits, and where he saw himself in “three or five years.”

The interviewee was able to promote an image of IS’ internal democracy and did not seem to regret his old life, saying, “we’re still buying and using smartphones and laptops, getting apartments and cars, using the internet frequently, sending our kids to school, and going to work.”

Evaluating the interview, Nathan S. French, assistant professor at the department of comparative religion at Miami University said that overall, it did not offer information that was not already stated by IS propaganda tools.

In 2014 and 2015, IS was on the rise and attracting thousands of foreign fighters. Interviews with them reflected strong beliefs and persistence.

But by the end of 2016, as IS suffered territorial losses and defeats, journalists started presenting a new image of delusional, regretful fighters.

In an interview published in 2017 by the Sydney Morning Herald after IS was pushed back from Iraq, journalist Michael Bachelard spoke with a defeated runaway fighter in Kirkuk.

The subject regretted joining the group, said it did not turn out to be the promised dream, and exposed atrocities and contradictions between their leaders’ actions and religion. In several instances, Bachelard insisted on the notion of crime and punishment, which he said could reach the death penalty.

Similarly, Kurdistan 24 covered, in 2017, stories on foreign fighters who ended up escaping IS and surrendering to security forces in Iraq, including an American Palestinian, a Swedish girl, and a Dutch woman.

Ragab argued in the same direction: a “hesitant terrorist” could be given space as sort of encouragement to resign, and a resigned extremist integrated in the society should be presented as an example of good behaviour.

You Might Also Like

Egypt’s Health Minister discuss bilateral cooperation with an Italian delegation 

Egypt condemns law allowing return of Israelis to 4 settlements

Egypt’s foreign minister phones Algerian counterpart over boosting ties

Opinion| Türkiye and Egypt: For better times with many opportunities

Drought caused 43,000 deaths in Somalia in 2022: UN 

TAGGED: extremists, interview, IS, Islamic state, journalism
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print
By Amira El-Fekki
Journalist in DNE's politics section, focusing on human rights, laws and legislations, press freedom, among other local political issues.
Previous Article World celebrates International Day for Elimination of Violence
Next Article Amer’s decisions will have positive effect on long term
1 Comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Ad image

Stay Connected

Facebook Like
Twitter Follow
Instagram Follow
Youtube Subscribe

Latest News

Popular video-sharing app TikTok was granted by the U.S. government a 15-day extension to reach a deal with U.S. buyers, a federal court filing showed Friday. This means the deadline for ByteDance, TikTok's Chinese parent company, to reach a deal with Oracle and Walmart has been extended from Nov. 12 to Nov. 27, according to the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia.
TikTok updates its community guidelines
Business
Strong representation of women in TV series of Ramadan 2023
Strong representation of women in TV series of Ramadan 2023
Culture Cinema
IFC to invest in Mediterrania Capital Partners’ fund to support African mid-cap businesses
IFC to invest in Mediterrania Capital Partners’ fund to support African mid-cap businesses
Business
Sukari gold mine’s production reaches 5.2 million ounces with $7.5bn revenues in February 2023
Sukari gold mine’s production reaches 5.2 million ounces with $7.5bn revenues in February 2023
Business
//
Egypt’s only independent daily newspaper in English. Discuss the country’s latest with the paper’s reporters, editors, and other readers.

Quick Link

  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

© 2023 DNE News. All Rights Reserved.

Join Us!

Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest news, podcasts etc..

Zero spam, Unsubscribe at any time.

Removed from reading list

Undo
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?