Daily News Egypt

Egypt has failed to meet US aid conditions: HRW - Daily News Egypt

Advertising Area

Advertising Area

Egypt has failed to meet US aid conditions: HRW

International rights watchdog urges US to acknowledge lack of progress in Egypt in aid review

US Secretary of State John Kerry will have the final say on whether or not the delivery of military aid should be resumed to Egypt (AFP PHOTO / PABLO MARTINEZ MONSIVAIS / POOL)
US Secretary of State John Kerry will have the final say on whether or not the delivery of military aid should be resumed to Egypt

Human Rights Watch (HRW) has urged the United States to acknowledge that “Egypt has made no progress on developing basic freedoms or on its democratic transition,” in its review to determine the resumption of military aid.

The rights group sent a letter to US Secretary of State John Kerry, which the group says was delivered last Monday.

The delivery of US military aid to Egypt was suspended last October pending “credible progress toward an inclusive, democratically elected civilian government through free and fair elections”. Under US law, Kerry will have the final say on whether or not the delivery of aid should be resumed.

Since the ouster of former president Mohamed Morsi on 3 July 2013, HRW claimed in their Saturday statement, the “military-backed government has killed well over 1,000 protestors and locked up more than 16,000 people”.  The group said that many of these incidents are “on the basis of their peaceful exercise of rights to free expression, association, and peaceful assembly.”

The group was also critical of the referral of 529 people to the death sentence, which is currently being reviewed by Grand Mufti Shawqy Allam. They said this “is but one example of an escalating climate of extreme political repression.”

HRW called on Kerry to consider specific steps that Egypt should take to demonstrate meaningful effort to develop basic freedoms.” These steps include “releasing political dissidents, amending the restrictive public assembly law it passed in November 2013, and initiating criminal investigations into the unlawful use of lethal force and abuse of detainees by security officials.”

Sarah Leah Whitson, Middle East Director for HRW expressed concern over the US’s review of its aid delivery to Egypt. “The question is no longer whether Egypt is on the road to democratic transition, but how much of its brute repression the US will paper over,” she said.

In January this year US congress made $1.3bn of military aid available to Egypt for Fiscal Year 2014. The aid is split into two packages, both of which are subject to conditions. Egypt must maintain “the strategic relationship with the US” and adhere to “its obligations under the 1979 Egypt-Israel Peace Treaty.”

The first package, worth $975m, can only be made available “if the Secretary of State certifies to the Committee on Appropriations that the government of Egypt has held a constitutional referendum, and is taking steps to support a democratic transition in Egypt.”

Following the passing of the constitution in January by a landslide vote, Kerry pointed to the concerns raised by Democracy International and the Carter Center over the conditions surrounding the referendum. He urged the interim government to investigate these concerns and to “fully implement those rights and freedoms that are guaranteed in the new constitution for the benefit of the Egyptian people”.

Kerry said in Match that he will decide “soon” on the issue of resuming aid to Egypt.

The second instalment, worth $576.8m, will be made available following the occurrence of parliamentary and presidential elections.

The US has been highly critical of some recent developments in Egypt, including the mass death sentence and the detainment of journalists and activists. The State Department has also maintained that it has been reviewing its relationship with Egypt since July 2013. The US has also stressed that it believes “it’s important to maintain a relationship with Egypt for a variety of security, economic, [and] regional reasons.”

Advertising Area

Advertising Area

  • sura

    Egypt is one of the prime sponsor of Al-shebabe which is register as a terrorist organization in the US list terrorism so how can Egypt fulfill US aid criteria

  • Bittertruth

    You forgot to mention broken Egypt and failed state Eritrea are trying to destabilize South Sudan, the youngest nation in the world. I don’t understand the rationale behind USA’s support to AMISOM in their war against Al Qaeda linked Alshabab terrorists when she is giving war machines to almost failed state Egypt who is funding and training AlShabaab. It would be a grave mistake if Sec Kerry decides to resume military aid to Egypt. In addition, as the international community know, the tyrant Sisi COUP government has killed well over 3000 innocent Egyptians so far and counting. According to HRW, nearly 16000 people including journalists, secular activists, lawyers, women children are jailed for peacefully demonstrating on the streets. Not to mention the wounded and tortured. A total U turn from democracy and human rights. We hope Mr Kerry will uphold the values of USA by not resuming military aid to the coup leaders.

  • Bittertruth

    Egypt’s poor need bread, electricity …etc. Certainly not a war machine. The military is already in control of over 40% of Egypt’s economy. US must focus on humanitarian support. Today Egypt is under the tight grip of military junta headed by Sisi and family (Hegazy). A Mubarak era corrupt judiciary and the notorious police are back again .

  • Jamela Radwan

    Perhaps you should look more critically at exactly who is saying that Egypt has not met human right goals. Credibility and motivation should be examined.
    Would it surprise you to know that Ms. Whitson also “marketed” Saif al-Islam Gaddafi (the son of Muammar Gaddafi) as a reformer? Engaged in fund raising with the Saudi elites including the Shura council where she marketed HRW’s work combating pro Israel “pressure groups”.?

    Would it also surprise you to know that Human Rights Watch signed off on renditions in talks with the Obama administration and I quote: “Under limited circumstances, there is a legitimate place” for renditions”, Tom
    Malinowski, the DC director for Human Rights Watch.

  • Pingback: Egypt News – 5 Apr 2014 | Africa()

  • sam enslow

    The US and NO other country owes Egypt anything. Contrary to the opinion of Egyptians, the world is not following events in Egypt with great concern. Egypt’s has seen fit to insult and slander most countries fom which it seeks aid. even when help is given, Egyptians ascribe the worst possible motives for it and steal as much as possible. See the example of the grain silos.

  • john

    How about changing the article to: “Human Rights Watch (HRW) has urged Egypt to acknowledge that the United States has made no progress on developing basic freedoms or on its democratic transition” and I would add “in relation to drone strikes in Pakistan as well as holding prisoners in Guantanamo Bay without a fair trial”.

Breaking News

No current breaking news

Daily News Egypt Android App Available for free download on Google play
Daily News Egypt Ios App Available for free download on APP Store