By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
DailynewsegyptDailynewsegypt
  • Home
  • Business
    BusinessShow More
    CBE to issue $540m worth of dollar-denominated T-bills on Monday 
    CBE to issue $540m worth of dollar-denominated T-bills on Monday 
    June 4, 2023
    HDB targets 25% growth in profits, various activities by 2023-end: CEO
    HDB targets 25% growth in profits, various activities by 2023-end: CEO
    June 4, 2023
    Bank ABC Egypt sees 158% profit growth in 1Q 2023, after merging with BLOM Bank
    Bank ABC Egypt sees 158% profit growth in 1Q 2023, after merging with BLOM Bank
    June 4, 2023
    146% growth in net profit of Attijariwafa bank Egypt reaching EGP 434.5m in 1Q 2023
    146% growth in net profit of Attijariwafa bank Egypt reaching EGP 434.5m in 1Q 2023
    June 4, 2023
    Al Ahly Pharos tops brokerage ranking in May
    Al Ahly Pharos tops brokerage ranking in May
    June 4, 2023
  • Politics
    PoliticsShow More
    GERD, Sudan, and Libya crises top Al-Sisi and Mauritanian counterpart talks 
    GERD, Sudan, and Libya crises top Al-Sisi and Mauritanian counterpart talks 
    June 4, 2023
    Iranian, Saudi FMs meet on bilateral ties
    Iranian, Saudi FMs meet on bilateral ties
    June 4, 2023
    Egypt’s PM inspects service, development projects in Alexandria
    Egypt’s PM inspects service, development projects in Alexandria
    June 4, 2023
    FM Shoukry attends inauguration ceremony of Turkish President
    FM Shoukry attends inauguration ceremony of Turkish President
    June 3, 2023
    1 Egyptian security personnel, 3 Israeli soldiers were killed in border shooting
    1 Egyptian security personnel, 3 Israeli soldiers were killed in border shooting 
    June 3, 2023
  • Interviews
    InterviewsShow More
    EFG Finance to launch unified platform gathering all its financing services: Alaa Al-Afifi
    EFG Finance to launch unified platform gathering all its financing services: Alaa Al-Afifi
    May 31, 2023
    I changed my artistic path to create ‘state of wonder’: Tarek Lotfi
    I changed my artistic path to create ‘state of wonder’: Tarek Lotfi
    May 25, 2023
    I adore Ramadan drama, ‘Telt Al-Talata’ series achieved great success: Ghada Abdel Razek
    I adore Ramadan drama, ‘Telt Al-Talata’ series achieved great success: Ghada Abdel Razek
    May 8, 2023
    We aim to establish Egypt as nearshore centre for Software AG for MET region: Rami Kichli
    We aim to establish Egypt as nearshore centre for Software AG for MET region: Rami Kichli
    April 29, 2023
    Egypt-Spain relations witness remarkable development in recent years: Spanish ambassador in Cairo
    Egypt-Spain relations witness remarkable development in recent years: Spanish ambassador in Cairo
    April 18, 2023
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
Reading: In other words: Who is the alternative to the Muslim Brotherhood?
Share
Notification
Latest News
CBE to issue $540m worth of dollar-denominated T-bills on Monday 
CBE to issue $540m worth of dollar-denominated T-bills on Monday 
Business
GERD, Sudan, and Libya crises top Al-Sisi and Mauritanian counterpart talks 
GERD, Sudan, and Libya crises top Al-Sisi and Mauritanian counterpart talks 
Politics Egypt
HDB targets 25% growth in profits, various activities by 2023-end: CEO
HDB targets 25% growth in profits, various activities by 2023-end: CEO
Banking
Bank ABC Egypt sees 158% profit growth in 1Q 2023, after merging with BLOM Bank
Bank ABC Egypt sees 158% profit growth in 1Q 2023, after merging with BLOM Bank
Banking
146% growth in net profit of Attijariwafa bank Egypt reaching EGP 434.5m in 1Q 2023
146% growth in net profit of Attijariwafa bank Egypt reaching EGP 434.5m in 1Q 2023
Banking
Aa
Aa
DailynewsegyptDailynewsegypt
  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
  • Advertise
© 2023 DNE News. All Rights Reserved.
Dailynewsegypt > Blog > Opinion > In other words: Who is the alternative to the Muslim Brotherhood?
Opinion

In other words: Who is the alternative to the Muslim Brotherhood?

Farid Zahran
Last updated: 2013/04/23 at 7:50 PM
By Farid Zahran 9 Min Read
Share
Farid Zahran
SHARE
Farid Zahran
Farid Zahran

Before answering this question, ask yourself: Has the Muslim Brotherhood succeeded in running the country? I ask this as someone who considers himself relatively involved in the country’s political circuit, who does not seek to judge the Muslim Brotherhood based on his own political convictions; however at the same time I do not pretend to speak on the matter from a purely objective standpoint. Rather I seek to judge the Muslim Brotherhood based on the standards they claim to have held themselves to, or, in other words, to the demands of the revolution. I would like to take a moment and pretend that I am an impartial political analyst, viewing events taking place in Egypt from somewhat of a bird’s eye view. With this in mind I will ask the question once again: Has the Muslim Brotherhood succeeded in running the country? From this removed vantage point, judging whether or not one has failed or succeeded in such regards could be measured by the extent to which one has successfully maintained peace and security throughout the country, or improved social mobility. The level of success in these fields could be measured by the popularity of the regime, or in the extent to which the Egyptian people as a whole take to expressing their happiness over the success of the revolution.

Regardless of one’s political persuasion, one cannot deny that by all accounts the Muslim Brotherhood has failed miserably. Judging on the one hand from the perspective of an international power with rooted interests in the region, one cannot say that they have succeeded. However the United States has put their money on the Muslim Brotherhood in the hopes that they will help protect Israel’s security in a way that other political organisations operating in the country could not. It is also true that the Muslim Brotherhood has taken steps to meet the demands of the International Monetary Fund and ensure the securing of the country’s pending $4.8bn loan, a feat Gamal Mubarak could not have achieved considering the decreasing popularity of the Mubarak regime.

The Brotherhood has also so far not taken any hostile positions regarding Washington’s stance towards Iran. However political stability in Egypt is an issue whose significance cannot be minimised, and rather serves as the bedrock upon which all else, in particular the success of those ambitions stated above, will follow. The Brotherhood’s inability to achieve such stability will inevitably bring it into confrontation with the country’s other political powers, specifically the “old” state and the country’s democracy movement. A fair assessment of any such confrontation must conclude that if one is to occur, the blame lies on the Muslim Brotherhood as opposed to the country’s other political forces, considering the Brotherhood’s alliance with the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF) during the early days of the revolution. Of course the Muslim Brotherhood during this time sought to deny the alliance, in an attempt to attract the cadres of Egypt’s democratic forces in their struggle against the SCAF. During this period a number of organisations opened their arms to the Muslim Brotherhood, especially during the presidential race between Mohamed Morsi and Ahmed Shafiq, which allowed Morsi to build a strong coalition of partners to triumph over his opponent. However it wasn’t long after Morsi’s victory until these partners began to withdraw one after the other from their coalition with the Muslim Brotherhood, to the point that even the Brotherhood’s Islamist allies began to do so, after disagreements with a number of the former’s prominent personalities, in particular Sayf Abd al-Fatah. Finally, the alliance between the Muslim Brotherhood and the Al-Nour Party even began to erode, after the resignation of Ahmed Mekki.

The real reason behind the failure of the Muslim Brotherhood to enforce peace and security throughout Egypt stems from their inability to absorb and form alliances with the country’s competing political forces, whether that be members of the “old” state, or Egypt’s democracy movement. In my estimation, this is not the result of a lack of efficiency or misjudgement on their part, but rather the intended exclusionary nature of the organisation, which views an alliance with other political forces merely as part of a trick or white lie, one which will not in the long run bind them to having to live up to the promises they have made to such allies. Isolation, resorting to violence, and engaging in shadowy political manoeuvring are all tactics that the Brotherhood has employed in seeking to avoid substantive political reconciliation. This reality manifested itself last Friday, during which point it appeared that the country’s democracy movement had learned a lesson as they were forced to retreat from the square. Similar events occurred previously when the Brotherhood sought to break up a peaceful sit-in at Egypt’s presidential palace. Such examples of violence achieved nothing for the Brotherhood except deepen their lack of credibility and further chip away at the confidence of the country’s “old” state and democracy movements regarding the intentions of the organisation.

This confidence gap is one that has grown so large that it cannot be bridged within the next several years, and so it is on the impartial observer, who is concerned only with how domestic politics in Egypt can help serve their interests, to ask themselves: Who within Egypt can serve as an alternative to the Muslim Brotherhood? This question forces us to ask another a series of questions, which are: Who is the most powerful political force in Egypt today? And is the country’s political scene separated only along religious and civil lines? Or is there a three way struggle between the country’s religious forces, democracy movement and “old” state?  If we go by the former logic, then the obvious alternative to the Muslim Brotherhood is the country’s civilian, democratic forces. However if we go by the three way split, which is closer to the reality on the ground than any other scenario,  then it is necessary to determine whether the better alternative is the “old” state or the country’s democracy movement. It goes without saying however that the “old” state is broken in a modern world, and does not have the ability to garner enough popular support via the ballot box to serve as an alternative to the Brotherhood. This leads us to the country’s opposition. Although it is currently weak, it is the only force that still maintains within its ranks what is left of the momentum of the revolution, and the only one that continues to inspire young and old alike. In my estimation, only Egypt’s democracy movement can successfully administer state organisations and institutions, and settle its disputes with Egypt’s various other political forces in a way that won’t lead to a protracted civil war, figurative or otherwise.

The country’s “old” state seeks to solve these issues with a quick knock-out punch, orchestrated by the army and supported by the region’s various local powers, with of course a green light given by the United States. However such plans are unrealistic and unlikely to succeed. For Egypt’s democracy movement, all that is left to do is continue protesting, engage in the country’s electoral process, and force the rest of Egypt to recognise our unique qualifications to run and administer the country.

END

You Might Also Like

Opinion| Russia and China promote stability in the Middle East after the US withdrawal from the region

Opinion| The American debt crisis and the 2024 elections

Opinion| Tips for startups operating in the tough environment of emerging markets

Opinion| Behind the scenes of the US-China conflict over Taiwan’s chips

Opinion| G7 Summit mobilizes Asian countries against China, while Beijing strengthens its position in Central Asia

TAGGED: Farid Zahran, Mekki, Morsi, Mubarak, Muslim Brotherhood, scaf, Shafiq
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print
By Farid Zahran
Farid Zahran is a publisher and writer. He is the co-founder of the Egyptian Social Democratic Party
Previous Article Leader’s Death Provides New Focus on Egypt’s Jews
Next Article Wear your whip to work week
2 Comments

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Ad image
Ad image

Stay Connected

Facebook Like
Twitter Follow
Instagram Follow
Youtube Subscribe

Latest News

CBE to issue $540m worth of dollar-denominated T-bills on Monday 
CBE to issue $540m worth of dollar-denominated T-bills on Monday 
Business
GERD, Sudan, and Libya crises top Al-Sisi and Mauritanian counterpart talks 
GERD, Sudan, and Libya crises top Al-Sisi and Mauritanian counterpart talks 
Politics Egypt
HDB targets 25% growth in profits, various activities by 2023-end: CEO
HDB targets 25% growth in profits, various activities by 2023-end: CEO
Banking
Bank ABC Egypt sees 158% profit growth in 1Q 2023, after merging with BLOM Bank
Bank ABC Egypt sees 158% profit growth in 1Q 2023, after merging with BLOM Bank
Banking
//
Egypt’s only independent daily newspaper in English. Discuss the country’s latest with the paper’s reporters, editors, and other readers.

Quick Link

  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

© 2023 DNE News. All Rights Reserved.

Join Us!

Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest news, podcasts etc..

Zero spam, Unsubscribe at any time.

Removed from reading list

Undo
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?