By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
DailynewsegyptDailynewsegypt
  • Home
  • Business
    BusinessShow More
    Communications Ministry cooperates with GIZ in e-government support project
    Communications Ministry cooperates with GIZ in e-government support project
    May 28, 2023
    Medmark and Howden host Cyber Insurance Seminar to help clients hedge against rising malware attacks
    Medmark and Howden host Cyber Insurance Seminar to help clients hedge against rising malware attacks
    May 28, 2023
    Supply chain disruption leads Ghabbour Auto sales to decline 40% in 1Q 2023
    Supply chain disruption leads Ghabbour Auto sales to decline 40% in 1Q 2023
    May 28, 2023
    MSMEDA offers free courses to develop industrial enterprises, increase export capabilities
    MSMEDA offers free courses to develop industrial enterprises, increase export capabilities
    May 28, 2023
    CFI Financial Group aims to expand in 4 new countries during 2023
    CFI Financial Group aims to expand in 4 new countries during 2023
    May 28, 2023
  • Politics
    PoliticsShow More
    Map of alliances affects second round of Turkish presidential election
    Map of alliances affects second round of Turkish presidential election
    May 28, 2023
    Restoring Sudan's stability will have positive impact on region: Al-Sisi
    Restoring Sudan’s stability will have positive impact on region: Al-Sisi
    May 28, 2023
    Armed clashes occur between Iranian, Afghan border guards
    Armed clashes occur between Iranian, Afghan border guards
    May 27, 2023
    UN warns Yemen's food insecurity remains serious threat
    UN warns Yemen’s food insecurity remains serious threat
    May 27, 2023
    Uganda dispatches team to investigate deadly attack on its peacekeepers in Somalia
    Uganda dispatches team to investigate deadly attack on its peacekeepers in Somalia
    May 27, 2023
  • Interviews
    InterviewsShow More
    I changed my artistic path to create ‘state of wonder’: Tarek Lotfi
    I changed my artistic path to create ‘state of wonder’: Tarek Lotfi
    May 25, 2023
    I adore Ramadan drama, ‘Telt Al-Talata’ series achieved great success: Ghada Abdel Razek
    I adore Ramadan drama, ‘Telt Al-Talata’ series achieved great success: Ghada Abdel Razek
    May 8, 2023
    We aim to establish Egypt as nearshore centre for Software AG for MET region: Rami Kichli
    We aim to establish Egypt as nearshore centre for Software AG for MET region: Rami Kichli
    April 29, 2023
    Egypt-Spain relations witness remarkable development in recent years: Spanish ambassador in Cairo
    Egypt-Spain relations witness remarkable development in recent years: Spanish ambassador in Cairo
    April 18, 2023
    "Al-Asly" series saw my first leading role in TV drama: Reham Abdel Ghafour
    “Al-Asly” series saw my first leading role in TV drama: Reham Abdel Ghafour
    April 16, 2023
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
Reading: The politics of remembering death
Share
Notification
Latest News
Communications Ministry cooperates with GIZ in e-government support project
Communications Ministry cooperates with GIZ in e-government support project
Business
Medmark and Howden host Cyber Insurance Seminar to help clients hedge against rising malware attacks
Medmark and Howden host Cyber Insurance Seminar to help clients hedge against rising malware attacks
Business
Supply chain disruption leads Ghabbour Auto sales to decline 40% in 1Q 2023
Supply chain disruption leads Ghabbour Auto sales to decline 40% in 1Q 2023
Business
MSMEDA offers free courses to develop industrial enterprises, increase export capabilities
MSMEDA offers free courses to develop industrial enterprises, increase export capabilities
Business
CFI Financial Group aims to expand in 4 new countries during 2023
CFI Financial Group aims to expand in 4 new countries during 2023
Business
Aa
Aa
DailynewsegyptDailynewsegypt
  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
  • Advertise
© 2023 DNE News. All Rights Reserved.
Dailynewsegypt > Blog > Opinion > The politics of remembering death
Opinion

The politics of remembering death

H.A. Hellyer
Last updated: 2013/10/08 at 6:16 PM
By H.A. Hellyer 8 Min Read
Share
Dr. H.A. Hellyer
Dr. H.A. Hellyer
SHARE
Dr. H.A. Hellyer
Dr. H.A. Hellyer

A group of peaceful protesters marched, and were set upon by official state forces – at the end of the violence, 28 people were dead, and more than 200 people were injured. At the time, human rights activists insisted that not only should an investigation take place into the killings: but that it should be an independent one, that the armed forces and security establishment could not influence or control, leading to the prosecution of those responsible.

That was 9 October 2011. Two years ago today – it was at Maspero, the headquarters of the national television apparatus. A largely (but not exclusively) Coptic Christian march intended to result in a sit-in there, identifying early on in Egypt’s revolution that whoever controls the national narrative, controls the levers of power. That same apparatus presented a narrative where the victims of these killings became the guilty party – and it was accepted by huge swathes of the public. A year ago, a group of pro-revolutionary activists refused to let the memory of Maspero die – and today, many of them, from varying & different political backgrounds will try to go to Maspero again. The very act of remembrance, for them, is an act of defiance against the powers that be – until those who are responsible for these deaths are brought to justice. Something that few among the powers that be intend.

Today, the country ought to be in national mourning. Mourning for those unarmed protesters who were killed two years ago today – and mourning for those who were killed three days ago. On 6 October 2013, while the country was generally celebrating the Egyptian military for its conduct in the 1973 October War, more than 50 pro-Muslim Brotherhood/anti-military protesters were killed in clashes in Cairo with the police and pro-state (armed) vigilante groups. The Ministry of Interior did not report any fatalities vis-à-vis the police forces. Indeed, there were no reports of any causality among state forces at all in these protests. A year from now, there will be another type of vigil, one assumes. And, one assumes, that vigil will still be demanding justice for the deaths – because, one continues to assume, no justice would have been served.

Egypt is certainly a land of ironies. While the killings at Maspero were taking place in 2011, the Muslim Brotherhood did not rally to the aid of those suffering from state violence. On the contrary – it validated and supported the then military regime of Field Marshal Tantawi. A year later, revolutionary activists took them to task on that, during the anniversary, when the Muslim Brotherhood attempted to rewrite its role in supporting the state narrative before. A year after that, it was the Muslim Brotherhood backed rally against the military that was attacked by state forces.

While that protest was resulting in dozens of unarmed civilians being killed, representatives of the state went to the memorial in Nasser City, to remember and pay their respects to the fallen military of the 1973 war. The ironies abound: while one faction remembers one tragedy, other members of their faction are carrying out another tragedy. That tragedy is against another faction, who not so long ago was content to validate another tragedy, carried out by the faction that is now against them, against yet another part of Egypt.

That is where, it seems, Egypt has come to: a place of tragedy and remembering. But only remembering the tragedy that is against your clique – your camp – your tribe – your cause. Not simply the tragedy of death; not simply the sadness accompanied by the loss of life. For all that people try to make it into a ‘human’ issue, where all blood ought to be considered as sacred, it is not that. It cannot be that, unless all blood, indeed, is sacred. Until then, the cycle continues – death, tragedy, and the remembrance of it, but only selectively. How unselective you are, when it comes to recognising and honouring those losses you know about, even if they are not personal to you and your cause, does say something about you.

The proponents of Tahrir Square demanded that a full and open investigation be undertaken to prosecute those who killed protesters during the 18 days, and those calls for public enquiries continued with the killings in Maspero. They continued also after the killings in Mohammed Mahmoud Street in November 2011; outside the Presidential Palace during Mohamed Morsi’s tenure in December 2012; outside the Republican Guard in July 2013 after his ouster – and the most intense loss of life of all. The forced dispersal of the pro-Morsi sit-in in Rabaa only three months ago, that led to what Human Rights Watch called, “the most serious incident of mass unlawful killings in modern Egyptian history”, is not the subject of a public enquiry. It’s hardly likely to be a place anytime soon where presidents and politicians speak of the mistakes that led to it, pray for the dead, and urge for discipline in ensuring it never happens again. Remember the dead, certainly – but only when it is your dead.

Today, all Egyptians ought to mourn the dead of Maspero. It should not be revolutionary activists at Maspero – it should be the state and all political forces. Next month, all of them ought to mourn the dead of Mohammed Mahmoud; in December all of them ought to mourn the dead of Ittahedeya; and next year, they ought to remember the dead of the Republican Guard killings, Rabaa, and the killings that just took place a few days ago. A single death where the state has even the slightest bit of responsibility should be the impetus for a wide scale enquiry.  Instead, we see dozens and hundreds dying – and still no deep security sector reform has taken place, with little likelihood of that happening soon.

There is another way. That other way is when all life is considered to be sacred – that, indeed, when one life is lost, all humankind is lost. That other way is what has been called for since the first days of the Egyptian revolution – accountability for the loss of life, and remembering its sacredness, regardless of who is killed, or who does the killings. Call it revolutionary. Call it ‘Islamic’. Or call it human. Call it what you want – but try to call it so that no Egyptian will ever call it anything ever again. Because if there are no more deadly tragedies, there won’t be a need to investigate them.

You Might Also Like

Africa Day: Egypt celebrates 60th anniversary of African unity

Opinion| Behind the scenes of the US-China conflict over Taiwan’s chips

Opinion| G7 Summit mobilizes Asian countries against China, while Beijing strengthens its position in Central Asia

Egypt aims to enhance contribution of IT sector to GDP: Talaat

Opinion| Biden Admin condemns Putin while helping Netanyahu establish apartheid state in Palestine

TAGGED: copts, Daily News Egypt, DNE, Egypt, H.A. Hellyer, islamists, maspero, massacre, october, politics
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print
By H.A. Hellyer
Dr H A Hellyer, a non-resident fellow at the Brookings Institution, is a Cairo-based specialist on Arab affairs, and relations between the Muslim world and the west. Fellow at ISPU, he was previously senior practice consultant at Gallup, and senior research fellow at Warwick University. Find him online @hahellyer and www.hahellyer.com .
Previous Article The Way of the Revolution Front: A critique
Next Article Christians ‘scapegoated’ after sit-in dispersals, says Amnesty International
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Ad image
Ad image

Stay Connected

Facebook Like
Twitter Follow
Instagram Follow
Youtube Subscribe

Latest News

Communications Ministry cooperates with GIZ in e-government support project
Communications Ministry cooperates with GIZ in e-government support project
Business
Medmark and Howden host Cyber Insurance Seminar to help clients hedge against rising malware attacks
Medmark and Howden host Cyber Insurance Seminar to help clients hedge against rising malware attacks
Business
Supply chain disruption leads Ghabbour Auto sales to decline 40% in 1Q 2023
Supply chain disruption leads Ghabbour Auto sales to decline 40% in 1Q 2023
Business
MSMEDA offers free courses to develop industrial enterprises, increase export capabilities
MSMEDA offers free courses to develop industrial enterprises, increase export capabilities
Business
//
Egypt’s only independent daily newspaper in English. Discuss the country’s latest with the paper’s reporters, editors, and other readers.

Quick Link

  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

© 2023 DNE News. All Rights Reserved.

Join Us!

Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest news, podcasts etc..

Zero spam, Unsubscribe at any time.

Removed from reading list

Undo
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?