You are here:  Home  >  Opinion  >  Current Article

Next generation Brotherhood

  /   2 Comments   /   1827 Views

Dr Mohamed Fouad

Dr Mohamed Fouad

It is no secret that the current political events in Egypt are dealing the Muslim Brotherhood perhaps the biggest blow in their 85 year history. I would dare say that this is much more severe than the assassination of Hassan Al-Banna or the execution of Sayyid Qutb.

The organisation, which has historically endured oppression from ruling regimes, is now finding itself in an all-too-familiar place; it is stripped of power, it has effectively alienated large segments of the population, it is demonised by the media and is slowly turning into a pariah.

Despite the rhetoric, the adrenaline, the campouts and the marches, it is clear that the Brotherhood is losing the fight to “bring back President Morsi.” The question is no longer will he ever return as president. The real question is: What now becomes of the Brotherhood?

In the immediate term, the current struggle serves an important purpose of keeping the group united in the face of the current dire circumstances. As Middle East Expert Khalil al-Anani noted: “The Brotherhood don’t have a clear mind to think about the future, they are simply attempting to maintain solidarity.” Venting their anger and betrayal is more beneficial to the Brotherhood at this stage than is asking tough questions like: why are we here and who is at fault? This blame game could certainly eat away the cohesiveness of the group. It is the tribulation and suffering which will act as the defense mechanism that will protect the group from shattering. So while the return of Morsi might be the flag that unites everyone, the demand is more mystical and symbolic than sensible at this stage.

In the medium term, the Brotherhood will need to make a choice whether to participate in mainstream politics again and stand for the upcoming parliamentary elections. If I was to take a guess, they will not – at least openly – participate in the elections. While lending support to some surrogates, they may opt to go back and reconsolidate their popular base which has certainly decayed over the past few months. There is a lot of deferred maintenance to do and a lot more damage control that needs to be accomplished.

Over the long term, we should expect the Brotherhood to make a comeback. The organisation has had a remarkable history of thriving in the face of pressure and confrontation. In fact, the “Erbakan to Erdogan” scenario might be very probable in the long term. The organisation would have had time to reflect on the many missteps it has taken. A new breed of leadership and public figures will need to emerge to shepherd the organisation through the next phase of its existence. Perhaps a consideration will need to be given to how exclusive the Brotherhood should remain; a feat which has been an ingredient of their success but also one that ultimately led to their failure. Of course, the timing of this longer term scenario will heavily depend on how successful political opponents are at bringing out a true alternative. One must not forget that the political victories mustered by the Islamists have always been made possible in the absence of an eligible alternative.

The game is far from over for the Brotherhood. We should not expect an organisation of this magnitude and especially one that is based on faith and creed to roll over and die. This is not merely a defunct political party, but a deep rooted social movement with a large cult following. Yes, they have had their moment in the spotlight and failed miserably, but that will not deter them from carrying on in their quest. Indeed the tide is too high for the organisation at this stage, but it will be wishful thinking to count the Brotherhood as dead.

About the author

Dr Mohamed Fouad

Dr Mohamed Fouad

Mohamed A. Fouad is a global expert on service quality as well as a political and social activist

  • DAMNtoMilitaryrule

    What a analyse (comment) from someone said to be a global expert. What happen to Egypt is so historic by his brutality an alienation of MB who just are victim as the naive liberal and secularist. To put a blame only on MB from an expert you said you are is to show an intellectual ignorance or ill intellectual to kiss the dictators in the region. Whoever PARTY took immediately power in Egypt after simulacrum fall of MUBARAK could have the same problem as MB unless you gave power to to mubarak old regime corrupt collaborators what they want. Egypt is suffering from long dictatorship that the mentality for a vast majority did not change yet. What I knew is when a PARTY won election it will govern by the program they set up during campaign. Unfortunately for MB old regime collaborators+ some ARAB corrupt league members have managed to sabotage everything.

    Wait and see if elbareid is true DEMOCRAT a bet is going to resign soon or later unless he choose to mask their machiavelli agenda to save face that everything is ok.

  • Ezzat Guirguis

    A good analysis. Very little mention of the World Council of Muslim Brotherhood.
    Also Erdogan’s role. He too needs to rethink his slip was showing badly!

    Fouad reflects my greatest fear. Our tendency to apathy, bungling and refusal to assume responsibility. Professor Heggi correctly identified Arab/ Egyptian defense mechanisms as: Paranoia and denial.
    Unless we get away from “.. the devil made me do it.” excuse, rollup our sleeves and make sacrifies the Brotherhood will return in force.

    Delighted and suprised I never expected the magnitude of the recent uprising. Can the initiative be maintained and redirected.

    Iam a pessimist and ay it cannot and will not. I pray yo God Iam wrong.

    If Iam right the Brotherhood will be back.

    Still we must not forget the role of International players in this and future scenarios.

You might also like...

James Dorsey

Erdogan chooses football for first-post election strike against Islamist opponents

Read More →