By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
DailynewsegyptDailynewsegypt
  • Home
  • Business
    BusinessShow More
    Opinion| Will the BRICS group give a lifeline to the Global South against the dominance of the US dollar?
    Opinion| Will the BRICS group give a lifeline to the Global South against the dominance of the US dollar?
    June 8, 2023
    AUR Capital concludes second securitized bond issuance of EGP 1.124bn 
    AUR Capital concludes second securitized bond issuance of EGP 1.124bn 
    June 8, 2023
    Matouk Bassiouny & Hennawy consults on more than 18 deals currently: Founding partner
    Matouk Bassiouny & Hennawy consults on more than 18 deals currently: Founding partner
    June 8, 2023
    Egypt’s petrochemicals exports surge 23% to $8.629bn in 2022
    Egypt’s petrochemicals exports surge 23% to $8.629bn in 2022
    June 8, 2023
    Trade exchange between Egypt, COMESA countries increases to $5.3bn in 2022: CAPMAS
    Trade exchange between Egypt, COMESA countries increases to $5.3bn in 2022: CAPMAS
    June 8, 2023
  • Politics
    PoliticsShow More
    Opinion| The suspension of Russia's participation in the START Treaty portends an imminent nuclear war
    Opinion| The suspension of Russia’s participation in the START Treaty portends an imminent nuclear war
    June 8, 2023
    Israel's neglect of Palestinian issue threatens regional, global security: Palestinian Foreign Ministry
    Israel’s neglect of Palestinian issue threatens regional, global security: Palestinian Foreign Ministry
    June 8, 2023
    Renewed clashes erupt in Sudan’s Omdurman, Khartoum
    Renewed clashes erupt in Sudan’s Omdurman, Khartoum
    June 8, 2023
    Abdel Ghaffar highlights Egypt’s government achievements in health sector during Africa Health ExCon
    Abdel Ghaffar highlights Egypt’s government achievements in health sector during Africa Health ExCon 
    June 8, 2023
    A legally binding agreement must be reached on GERD: Al-Sisi
    A legally binding agreement must be reached on GERD: Al-Sisi
    June 8, 2023
  • Interviews
    InterviewsShow More
    EFG Finance to launch unified platform gathering all its financing services: Alaa Al-Afifi
    EFG Finance to launch unified platform gathering all its financing services: Alaa Al-Afifi
    May 31, 2023
    I changed my artistic path to create ‘state of wonder’: Tarek Lotfi
    I changed my artistic path to create ‘state of wonder’: Tarek Lotfi
    May 25, 2023
    I adore Ramadan drama, ‘Telt Al-Talata’ series achieved great success: Ghada Abdel Razek
    I adore Ramadan drama, ‘Telt Al-Talata’ series achieved great success: Ghada Abdel Razek
    May 8, 2023
    We aim to establish Egypt as nearshore centre for Software AG for MET region: Rami Kichli
    We aim to establish Egypt as nearshore centre for Software AG for MET region: Rami Kichli
    April 29, 2023
    Egypt-Spain relations witness remarkable development in recent years: Spanish ambassador in Cairo
    Egypt-Spain relations witness remarkable development in recent years: Spanish ambassador in Cairo
    April 18, 2023
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
Reading: Quantum mechanics: how the future might influence the past
Share
Notification
Latest News
Egyptian drama and cinema industry: challenges and solutions
Egyptian drama and cinema industry: challenges and solutions
Cinema Culture
Opinion| The suspension of Russia's participation in the START Treaty portends an imminent nuclear war
Opinion| The suspension of Russia’s participation in the START Treaty portends an imminent nuclear war
Opinion Politics
Opinion| Will the BRICS group give a lifeline to the Global South against the dominance of the US dollar?
Opinion| Will the BRICS group give a lifeline to the Global South against the dominance of the US dollar?
Opinion Business
AI outperforms standard risk model for predicting breast cancer
AI outperforms standard risk model for predicting breast cancer
Science
AUR Capital concludes second securitized bond issuance of EGP 1.124bn 
AUR Capital concludes second securitized bond issuance of EGP 1.124bn 
Business
Aa
Aa
DailynewsegyptDailynewsegypt
  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
  • Advertise
© 2023 DNE News. All Rights Reserved.
Dailynewsegypt > Blog > Science > Quantum mechanics: how the future might influence the past
Science

Quantum mechanics: how the future might influence the past

TheConversation
Last updated: 2023/03/21 at 5:30 PM
By TheConversation 9 Min Read
Share
Quantum mechanics- how the future might influence the past
SHARE

Huw Price, University of Cambridge and Ken Wharton, San José State University – In 2022, the physics Nobel prize was awarded for experimental work showing that the quantum world must break some of our fundamental intuitions about how the universe works.

Contents
CausationQuantum retrocausalitySuperdeterminismEvidence

Many look at those experiments and conclude that they challenge “locality” — the intuition that distant objects need a physical mediator to interact. And indeed, a mysterious connection between distant particles would be one way to explain these experimental results.

Others instead think the experiments challenge “realism” — the intuition that there’s an objective state of affairs underlying our experience. After all, the experiments are only difficult to explain if our measurements are thought to correspond to something real. Either way, many physicists agree about what’s been called “the death by experiment” of local realism.

But what if both of these intuitions can be saved, at the expense of a third? A growing group of experts think that we should abandon instead the assumption that present actions can’t affect past events. Called “retrocausality”, this option claims to rescue both locality and realism.


This is article is accompanied by a podcast series called Great Mysteries of Physics which uncovers the greatest mysteries facing physicists today – and discusses the radical proposals for solving them.


Causation

What is causation anyway? Let’s start with the line everyone knows: correlation is not causation. Some correlations are causation, but not all. What’s the difference?

Consider two examples. (1) There’s a correlation between a barometer needle and the weather – that’s why we learn about the weather by looking at the barometer. But no one thinks that the barometer needle is causing the weather. (2) Drinking strong coffee is correlated with a raised heart rate. Here it seems right to say that the first is causing the second.

The difference is that if we “wiggle” the barometer needle, we won’t change the weather. The weather and the barometer needle are both controlled by a third thing, the atmospheric pressure – that’s why they are correlated. When we control the needle ourselves, we break the link to the air pressure, and the correlation goes away.

But if we intervene to change someone’s coffee consumption, we’ll usually change their heart rate, too. Causal correlations are those that still hold when we wiggle one of the variables.

These days, the science of looking for these robust correlations is called “causal discovery”. It’s a big name for a simple idea: finding out what else changes when we wiggle things around us.

In ordinary life, we usually take for granted that the effects of a wiggle are going to show up later than the wiggle itself. This is such a natural assumption that we don’t notice that we’re making it.

But nothing in the scientific method requires this to happen, and it is easily abandoned in fantasy fiction. Similarly in some religions, we pray that our loved ones are among the survivors of yesterday’s shipwreck, say. We’re imagining that something we do now can affect something in the past. That’s retrocausality.

Quantum retrocausality

John Stewart Bell.
John Bell. wikipedia/cern, CC BY-SA

The quantum threat to locality (that distant objects need a physical mediator to interact) stems from an argument by the Northern Ireland physicist John Bell in the 1960s. Bell considered experiments in which two hypothetical physicists, Alice and Bob, each receive particles from a common source. Each chooses one of several measurement settings, and then records a measurement outcome. Repeated many times, the experiment generates a list of results.

Bell realised that quantum mechanics predicts that there will be strange correlations (now confirmed) in this data. They seemed to imply that Alice’s choice of setting has a subtle “nonlocal” influence on Bob’s outcome, and vice versa – even though Alice and Bob might be light years apart. Bell’s argument is said to pose a threat to Albert Einstein’s theory of special relativity, which is an essential part of modern physics.

But that’s because Bell assumed that quantum particles don’t know what measurements they are going to encounter in the future. Retrocausal models propose that Alice’s and Bob’s measurement choices affect the particles back at the source. This can explain the strange correlations, without breaking special relativity.

In recent work, we’ve proposed a simple mechanism for the strange correlation – it involves a familiar statistical phenomenon called Berkson’s bias (see our popular summary here).

There’s now a thriving group of scholars who work on quantum retrocausality. But it’s still invisible to some experts in the wider field. It gets confused for a different view called “superdeterminism”.

Superdeterminism

Superdeterminism agrees with retrocausality that measurement choices and the underlying properties of the particles are somehow correlated.

But superdeterminism treats it like the correlation between the weather and the barometer needle. It assumes there’s some mysterious third thing – a “superdeterminer” – that controls and correlates both our choices and the particles, the way atmospheric pressure controls both the weather and the barometer.

So superdeterminism denies that measurement choices are things we are free to wiggle at will, they are predetermined. Free wiggles would break the correlation, just as in the barometer case. Critics object that superdeterminism thus undercuts core assumptions necessary to undertake scientific experiments. They also say that it means denying free will, because something is controlling both the measurement choices and particles.

These objections don’t apply to retrocausality. Retrocausalists do scientific causal discovery in the usual free, wiggly way. We say it is folk who dismiss retrocausality who are forgetting the scientific method, if they refuse to follow the evidence where it leads.

Evidence

What is the evidence for retrocausality? Critics ask for experimental evidence, but that’s the easy bit: the relevant experiments just won a Nobel Prize. The tricky part is showing that retrocausality gives the best explanation of these results.

We’ve mentioned the potential to remove the threat to Einstein’s special relativity. That’s a pretty big hint, in our view, and it’s surprising it has taken so long to explore it. The confusion with superdeterminism seems mainly to blame.

In addition, we and others have argued that retrocausality makes better sense of the fact that the microworld of particles doesn’t care about the difference between past and future.

We don’t mean that it is all plain sailing. The biggest worry about retrocausation is the possibility of sending signals to the past, opening the door to the paradoxes of time travel. But to make a paradox, the effect in the past has to be measured. If our young grandmother can’t read our advice to avoid marrying grandpa, meaning we wouldn’t come to exist, there’s no paradox. And in the quantum case, it’s well known that we can never measure everything at once.

Still, there’s work to do in devising concrete retrocausal models that enforce this restriction that you can’t measure everything at once. So we’ll close with a cautious conclusion. At this stage, it’s retrocausality that has the wind in its sails, so hull down towards the biggest prize of all: saving locality and realism from “death by experiment”.

Huw Price, Emeritus Fellow, Trinity College, University of Cambridge and Ken Wharton, Professor of Physics and Astronomy, San José State University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

You Might Also Like

AI outperforms standard risk model for predicting breast cancer

Chimpanzees’ communication development echoes human infants

Does multimorbidity impact chronic disease treatment?

Extreme weather led to two million deaths, $4trn losses over last 50 years

Remote monitoring reduces heart failure hospitalizations, improves quality of life

Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print
Previous Article Egypt, Turkey are not competitors in Libya: FM Cavusoglu  Egypt, Turkey are not competitors in Libya: FM Cavusoglu 
Next Article American University in Cairo (AUC) launches Excellence Scholarship Program to support outstanding students AUC launches Excellence Scholarship Program to support outstanding students
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Ad image
Ad image

Stay Connected

Facebook Like
Twitter Follow
Instagram Follow
Youtube Subscribe

Latest News

Egyptian drama and cinema industry: challenges and solutions
Egyptian drama and cinema industry: challenges and solutions
Cinema Culture
Opinion| The suspension of Russia's participation in the START Treaty portends an imminent nuclear war
Opinion| The suspension of Russia’s participation in the START Treaty portends an imminent nuclear war
Opinion Politics
Opinion| Will the BRICS group give a lifeline to the Global South against the dominance of the US dollar?
Opinion| Will the BRICS group give a lifeline to the Global South against the dominance of the US dollar?
Opinion Business
AI outperforms standard risk model for predicting breast cancer
AI outperforms standard risk model for predicting breast cancer
Science
//
Egypt’s only independent daily newspaper in English. Discuss the country’s latest with the paper’s reporters, editors, and other readers.

Quick Link

  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

© 2023 DNE News. All Rights Reserved.

Join Us!

Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest news, podcasts etc..

Zero spam, Unsubscribe at any time.

Removed from reading list

Undo
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?