By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
DailynewsegyptDailynewsegypt
  • Home
  • Business
    BusinessShow More
    Egypt to issue new bonds for climate, social goals
    Egypt to issue new bonds for climate, social goals
    September 27, 2023
    Saudi Public Investment Fund eyes stake in Palm Hills Development
    Saudi Public Investment Fund eyes stake in Palm Hills Development
    September 27, 2023
    UNDP, MBRF launch online learning initiative for Arab countries
    UNDP, MBRF launch online learning initiative for Arab countries
    September 27, 2023
    Egypt Post invests in Roaderz platform to enhance e-commerce, delivery services
    Egypt Post invests in Roaderz platform to enhance e-commerce, delivery services
    September 27, 2023
    GAFI to grant 45 more golden licences to boost investment
    GAFI to grant 45 more golden licences to boost investment
    September 27, 2023
  • Politics
    PoliticsShow More
    Egypt’s Irrigation Minister highlights climate challenges for water sector
    Egypt’s Irrigation Minister highlights climate challenges for water sector
    September 27, 2023
    CCCPA, Senghor University join forces for African peace, development
    CCCPA, Senghor University join forces for African peace, development
    September 27, 2023
    Arab League chief urges more funding, investment for food security
    Arab League chief urges more funding, investment for food security
    September 27, 2023
    Egypt denounces Houthi attack on Bahraini forces in Saudi Arabia
    Egypt denounces Houthi attack on Bahraini forces in Saudi Arabia
    September 27, 2023
    vPalestine urges international action to end Israeli occupation, crimes
    Palestine urges international action to end Israeli occupation, crimes
    September 26, 2023
  • Interviews
    InterviewsShow More
    Microsoft Egypt aims to provide advanced AI models, build solid AI ecosystem: Mirna Arif
    Microsoft Egypt aims to provide advanced AI models, build solid AI ecosystem: Mirna Arif
    September 18, 2023
    I love privacy, and I am not concerned about competition: Yasmine Sabry
    I love privacy, and I am not concerned about competition: Yasmine Sabry
    September 14, 2023
    Sustainability, digital transformation at the heart of our strategy: Heidelberg Materials Egypt
    Sustainability, digital transformation at the heart of our strategy: Heidelberg Materials Egypt
    September 12, 2023
    India welcomes Egypt's BRICS membership: Boosting trade, investment, and access to strategic commodities
    India welcomes Egypt’s BRICS membership: Boosting trade, investment, and access to strategic commodities
    September 11, 2023
    The box office is not a measure of success: Basma Hassan
    The box office is not a measure of success: Basma
    September 6, 2023
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
Reading: Op-ed review: The new constitution
Share
Notification
Latest News
Genetically engineering associations between plants and nitrogen-fixing microbes could lessen dependence on synthetic fertilizer
Genetically engineering associations between plants and nitrogen-fixing microbes could lessen dependence on synthetic fertilizer
Science
Earthworms contribute to 6.5% of global grain production, says new research
Earthworms contribute to 6.5% of global grain production, says new research
Science
Researchers build and test a framework for achieving climate resilience across diverse fisheries
Researchers build and test a framework for achieving climate resilience across diverse fisheries
Science
Egypt to issue new bonds for climate, social goals
Egypt to issue new bonds for climate, social goals
Business
Saudi Public Investment Fund eyes stake in Palm Hills Development
Saudi Public Investment Fund eyes stake in Palm Hills Development
Business
Aa
Aa
DailynewsegyptDailynewsegypt
  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
  • Advertise
© 2023 DNE News. All Rights Reserved.
Dailynewsegypt > Blog > Opinion > Op-ed review: The new constitution
Opinion

Op-ed review: The new constitution

Thoraia Abou Bakr
Last updated: 2013/12/09 at 7:04 PM
By Thoraia Abou Bakr 9 Min Read
Share
SHARE

The upcoming referendum on the new constitution has been on the minds of many columnists. Predictably, many columns are concerned with dissecting the new constitution and exploring its pros and cons.

The constitution and its political and geographic disasters

5-2 a Al-Khesht

Mohamed Othman Al-Khesht

Al Watan Newspaper

Columnist Al-Khesht explores how the political blunders following after 25 January 2011 hindered the revolution, lamenting the three-year delay in implementing its aims. However he indicates that “the first step is about to be completed: The constitution’s draft has been written and all that is left is its ratification.”

Through his columns, Al-Khesht says he has attempted to advise the Constituent Assembly. “A strong but not dictatorial ruler is essential; fair but not oppressive,” he says, adding that order does not justify dictatorship. He warns of a constitution which masks dictatorship under the guise of democracy.

Al-Khesht further explains that this means returning to an understanding of Islam which does not polarise, but one that seeks common ground and mutual understanding. He adds that even though there are some objections to the current draft of the constitution, “it is a bridge to safety.” He then outlines his reasons for the ratification of the constitution.

Firstly, Al-Khesht reasons that the new constitution strengthens the state apparatus and decreases the powers of the president. “It presents [us] with a partially presidential system and balances between [the different] powers, therefore it prevents [us] from creating a new dictator,” Al-Khesht writes.

Secondly, Al-Khesht writes that the new constitution promotes freedom and personal rights. “It is committed to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other international agreements concerning human rights which Egypt ratified,” says, and points out that the new constitution gives women more rights such the right to be appointed in the judiciary and other legal bodies, and provides mechanisms to protect them from violence.

Third, the constitution protects freedom of worship, and promises to build places of worship for the three celestial religions as regulated by law.

Fourth, the state is committed to solve the problem of illegal construction and informal housing and promises to provide alternatives. The new constitution Al-Khesht points out is also committed to improve “the quality of life and the health of citizens.”

Fifth, the constitution dictates that governmental spending on education will not be less than 4% of the Gross National Product (GNP).

Sixth, in response to perhaps the most contentious issue, the military trials of civilians, Al-Khesht points out that the new constitution restricts the mandates of military courts and that these courts are only concerned with a limited number of offences stating that “there are only 14 specific crimes such as the assault on military facilities,” which would fall under the jurisdiction of military courts. He emphasises that this is an improvement of the 2012 constitution which did not specify the crimes in which military courts would have authority.

Al-Khesht concludes his argument stating that enforcing rather than implementing the new constitution remains the biggest challenge.

 

5-2 b Al-Sayed

The intelligent reader’s guide to understanding the new constitution

Mostafa Kamel Al-Sayed

Al-Shorouk Newspaper

Al-Sayed starts his column by reviewing the parties which were most interested in the process of drafting the new constitution: the armed forces, civil forces that participated in the second wave of the January revolution, religious organisations such as Al-Nour Party, Al-Azhar and “the churches.”  Al-Sayed, also points out that the Muslim Brotherhood was absent from the drafting of the new constitution.

He adds that these parties used whatever power they had to steer the process in various directions that would serve their own interests. The most powerful of these was the armed forces, despite the fact that it did not represent the  majority in the Constitutional Assembly. However Al-Sayad points out that the armed forces were able to exercise a disproportionate hold on the delegation due to its strict “influence on the political community.”

Al-Sayed believes that both religious and civil political groups are heavily influenced by the armed forces,  allowing the military to have a major role in drafting the new constitution. Al-Nour Party made many concessions in order to avoid the implementation of Article 74, which prohibits the establishment of political parties based on religion.

“Al-Azhar representatives were satisfied with the mere mentioning of Al-Azhar in the constitution. They conceded to the necessity of consulting it in anything related to Sharia as dictated in the 2012 constitution,” Al-Sayed writes.  He adds that the only argument in which religious parties were engaged concerned the inclusion of the term “civil state” resulting in a final verdict in which the assembly agreed upon the term “a civil government.”

Al-Sayed believes that civil parties exercised a disproportionate amount of influence within the assembly, which does not accurately reflect their support on the ground. He explains that the committee’s different commissions were comprised mainly of people from civil society. He adds that the assembly had to concede to pressure from religious parties, which influence a large section of the society and also in fear of what supporters of the Brotherhood might do during the referendum.

As a result of this pressure, the term “non-Muslims” was eliminated from Article 3 as was the idea of a “civil state.”

Al-Sayed believes those belonging to factional interests were able to “preserve the rights that they were given in the 2012 constitution”.  Pointing out that even though the constitutional court regained its prior status before the 2012 constitution, the draft did not specify the number of judicial members in this court. It also did not enable non-judiciary entities to nominate members for the constitutional court. In addition, the workers and farmers were unable to maintain their 50% quota in the new parliament.

Al-Sayed explains that the armed forces – through its representative in the assembly – did not offer any concessions or let go of any of its demands. Its budget remains untouchable as it is presented as a number to the parliament and it is not subject to discussion.

Further jurisdiction of military courts and their right to try civilians remains ambiguous and open to interpretation. The appointment of the defence minister can only appointed with the agreement of the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF).  This leaves the control of the armed forces outside the authority of a civilian rule.

Al-Sayed points out that a party absent from the political process entirely, namely the National Democratic Party, incidentally made great gains in the new constitution. For example, the new constitution dropped the article banning members of the former regime from assuming roles in the new government. Al-Sayed mentions that this might be due to the constitutional court’s objection to that article which was passed in the 2012 constitution.

Al-Sayed concludes, however, that despite all of these objections, the constitution remains the best option for Egyptians seeking progress.

You Might Also Like

Opinion| Switzerland, a reliable partner of Egypt in a changing world

Egypt plans to sell stakes in AlexBank, Vodafone, and other assets by June 2024

Egypt, Sudan, and Ethiopia resume talks on GERD in Addis Ababa

Egypt, Jordan, and Iraq discuss economic, political cooperation in New York

Egypt, India affirm their strategic partnership, discuss regional issues

TAGGED: Daily News Egypt, DNE, draft, Egypt, new constitution, referendum, voting
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print
Previous Article Message on international anti-corruption day
Next Article Egypt’s others
2 Comments

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Ad image
Ad image

Stay Connected

Facebook Like
Twitter Follow
Instagram Follow
Youtube Subscribe

Latest News

Genetically engineering associations between plants and nitrogen-fixing microbes could lessen dependence on synthetic fertilizer
Genetically engineering associations between plants and nitrogen-fixing microbes could lessen dependence on synthetic fertilizer
Science
Earthworms contribute to 6.5% of global grain production, says new research
Earthworms contribute to 6.5% of global grain production, says new research
Science
Researchers build and test a framework for achieving climate resilience across diverse fisheries
Researchers build and test a framework for achieving climate resilience across diverse fisheries
Science
Egypt to issue new bonds for climate, social goals
Egypt to issue new bonds for climate, social goals
Business
//
Egypt’s only independent daily newspaper in English. Discuss the country’s latest with the paper’s reporters, editors, and other readers.

Quick Link

  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

© 2023 DNE News. All Rights Reserved.

Join Us!

Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest news, podcasts etc..

Zero spam, Unsubscribe at any time.

Removed from reading list

Undo
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?