By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
DailynewsegyptDailynewsegypt
  • Home
  • Business
    BusinessShow More
    Suez Canal Bank signs protocol with Chinese TEDA to support investment in SCZone
    Suez Canal Bank signs protocol with Chinese TEDA to support investment in SCZone
    June 1, 2023
    Egypt, GIZ sign agreement of €8m to support e-government, innovation in management
    Egypt, GIZ sign agreement of €8m to support e-government, innovation in management
    June 1, 2023
    Egypt hosts InnoXera Summit on education in artificial intelligenceage
    Egypt hosts InnoXera Summit on education in artificial intelligenceage
    June 1, 2023
    Egyptian economy offers great competitive advantage, diversified investment opportunities: Ayman Soliman
    Egyptian economy offers great competitive advantage, diversified investment opportunities: Ayman Soliman
    June 1, 2023
    Egypt's new membership in New Development Bank enhances South-South cooperation: Al-Mashat
    Egypt’s new membership in New Development Bank enhances South-South cooperation: Al-Mashat
    June 1, 2023
  • Politics
    PoliticsShow More
    India train crash kills at least 207, injures hundreds 
    India train crash kills at least 207, injures hundreds 
    June 3, 2023
    Madbouly reaffirms Egypt’s unwavering assistance for Palestine
    Madbouly reaffirms Egypt’s unwavering assistance for Palestine
    June 1, 2023
    Egypt reiterates firm position in support of Palestinian cause: Shoukry
    Egypt reiterates firm position in support of Palestinian cause: Shoukry
    June 1, 2023
    Egypt and France discuss joint cooperation in the health sector
    Egypt and France discuss joint cooperation in the health sector 
    June 1, 2023
    AU praises Egypt's role in achieving sustainable peace in Africa despite challenges
    AU praises Egypt’s role in achieving sustainable peace in Africa despite challenges
    May 31, 2023
  • Interviews
    InterviewsShow More
    EFG Finance to launch unified platform gathering all its financing services: Alaa Al-Afifi
    EFG Finance to launch unified platform gathering all its financing services: Alaa Al-Afifi
    May 31, 2023
    I changed my artistic path to create ‘state of wonder’: Tarek Lotfi
    I changed my artistic path to create ‘state of wonder’: Tarek Lotfi
    May 25, 2023
    I adore Ramadan drama, ‘Telt Al-Talata’ series achieved great success: Ghada Abdel Razek
    I adore Ramadan drama, ‘Telt Al-Talata’ series achieved great success: Ghada Abdel Razek
    May 8, 2023
    We aim to establish Egypt as nearshore centre for Software AG for MET region: Rami Kichli
    We aim to establish Egypt as nearshore centre for Software AG for MET region: Rami Kichli
    April 29, 2023
    Egypt-Spain relations witness remarkable development in recent years: Spanish ambassador in Cairo
    Egypt-Spain relations witness remarkable development in recent years: Spanish ambassador in Cairo
    April 18, 2023
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
Reading: The struggles of the Mubarak-era asset recovery process
Share
Notification
Latest News
India train crash kills at least 207, injures hundreds 
India train crash kills at least 207, injures hundreds 
Politics Breaking News World
Adding flavour of innovation to F&B industry in Africa
Adding flavour of innovation to F&B industry in Africa 
Women
Egypt’s Women on Boards Indicator records 19.7% in 2022 with 3% growth
Egypt’s Women on Boards Indicator records 19.7% in 2022 with 3% growth
Women
Suez Canal Bank signs protocol with Chinese TEDA to support investment in SCZone
Suez Canal Bank signs protocol with Chinese TEDA to support investment in SCZone
Banking
Egypt, GIZ sign agreement of €8m to support e-government, innovation in management
Egypt, GIZ sign agreement of €8m to support e-government, innovation in management
Business
Aa
Aa
DailynewsegyptDailynewsegypt
  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
  • Advertise
© 2023 DNE News. All Rights Reserved.
Dailynewsegypt > Blog > Opinion > The struggles of the Mubarak-era asset recovery process
Opinion

The struggles of the Mubarak-era asset recovery process

Daily News Egypt
Last updated: 2012/10/04 at 5:56 PM
By Daily News Egypt 8 Min Read
Share
SHARE

By Waleed Nassar

Egypt’s post-revolution efforts to repatriate Mubarak-era assets have garnered widespread international attention since his ouster in 2011.There are serious questions concerning what progress has been made over the past year and a half, however, as the international recovery process has not yielded the results many had hoped.

For instance, only three countries have officially frozen funds, the United Kingdom, Switzerland and Spain, with varying degrees of actual oversight, despite the great likelihood that illicit assets have widely proliferated across the globe into numerous other countries.

Similarly disconcerting, several countries where Mubarak assets are rumored to have landed, including the United States and Canada, have enacted largely symbolic measures, failing to freeze a single dollar worth of assets.

Some opine that the lack of results stem from a largely un-sympathetic international community that does not desire to come down too hard on Mubarak, a once loyal former ally. This, however, fails to capture the full picture, as the reasons for the frustration of Egypt’s attempts run much deeper than a weak international will to assist.

Recently, news of the UK’s failure to properly freeze Mubarak-era assets has come to light. The British Treasury’s Asset Freezing Unit had frozen approximately $138 million in Egyptian assets after Mubarak’s fall, however, asix-month BBC investigation, broadcast in September, highlighted public documents showing that Mubarak assets in London had yet to be frozen by the UK government.

This, despite the UK’s public commitment to do so and a European Union sanctions agreement that they signed in March 2011 requiring the same.While various accusations of wrongdoing have been levelled at the UK government, it is important toidentify the proper causes for complaint.

The Egyptian government has valid concerns regarding the UK’s shoddy administration of their asset freeze. For instance, as the BBC investigation uncovered, many bank accounts and real property of regime officials that were supposed to have been frozen were not.

This, in all likelihood, has allowed for the funds to move outside the UK, invariably adding further layers of complexity and challenges towards ultimate recovery of those sums. The British have also stymied the Egyptian authorities’ investigation into the nature and ownership of the frozen assets, citing domestic privacy laws. Due to public backlash in the wake of the BBC investigation, however, the British were quick to appoint experienced practitioners to assist the Egyptians to navigate those very same privacy laws.

The Egyptian government pronouncements have also, at times, illustrated a misapprehension of the specifics of the UK’s failures, as well as a greater lack of understanding of the general asset recovery process.For example, some Egyptian officials have publicly complained that it should be easy enough for the British to return the assets, as they have already been located and frozen, and that their refusal to do so evidences bad faith. This misconstrues the process.

Asking the British Treasury to return the funds is similar to requesting an arresting officer to conduct a trial of an arrested person, secure a conviction and pronounce a sentence.Just as the officer merely has the authority to locate and arrest an individual and it is for the judicial system to determine guilt and dispense justice, the same too goes for illicit asset repatriation.

The UK has strict laws and procedures for asset repatriation, even after a freeze, and the Egyptian government will have to navigate the proper legal channels to satisfy the procedural and evidentiary hurdles before ultimate recovery of the frozen funds.

More broadly speaking, the transitional Egyptian government failed to take the proper steps to ensure a smooth path to recovery of illicit assets housed abroad.Egyptian prosecutors did not secure convictions on the corruption charges that were laid against Mubarak and his two sons in the recent “trial of the century,” although they did get convictions related to the ordering of the deaths of the estimated 850 people killed in the revolution.

Without underlying domestic findings of law clearly stating that the funds in question were gained through illicit means, there is shaky foundation upon which to build the asset recovery process.The evidence of wrongdoing is in Egypt, comprising of documents and witnesses, not in the foreign countries where the assets lie.

Rumours and innuendo simply do not satisfy the high legal burden of proof necessary to allow for repatriation of the assets.Going forward, Egypt needs to aggressively pursue the necessary convictions and predicate legal findings needed to effect proper recovery. If they choose not to, it will be disingenuous for any Egyptian official to blame failure on outside countries.

It is necessary to understand the exact reasons for the troubles, so as to determine how best to proceed to obtain maximum recovery. Despite the challenges ahead, and the limited successes the asset recovery process has achieved, the window to recover the assets frozen is still open. For example, the Swiss have provided a three year period for the Egyptians to effect repatriation of the over $700 million frozen there, while Canada has provided a five year window for potential freezes.

Additionally, Egypt’s greater efforts to track undisclosed assets have barely scratched the surface and with proper forensic investigation and coordinated legal efforts many new avenues of recovery may emerge. Conducting a thorough asset recovery process necessitates more than sending a delegation of officials to diplomatic meetings abroad and receiving assurances from various governments, but, rather, requires a much more sophisticated approach than what has been exhibited to date.

Mubarak and his corrupt cadre of cronies are known to have employed many of the most sophisticated international accountants and lawyers illicit money can buy, and to retrieve that money will require a level of sophistication that is on par.The road to ultimate recovery will invariably be long and fraught with a multitude of hurdles, however, it may successfully be navigated with proper legal understanding and a domestic political will to press forward.

Waleed Nassar is an associate at Lewis Baach PLLC,specialising in international dispute resolution and foreign asset tracing and is a member of the Egyptian American Rule of Law Association

You Might Also Like

Egypt and France discuss joint cooperation in the health sector 

Opinion| Russia and China promote stability in the Middle East after the US withdrawal from the region

Opinion| The American debt crisis and the 2024 elections

Opinion| Tips for startups operating in the tough environment of emerging markets

Egypt, Italy discuss joint cooperation in environment

TAGGED: asset, corruption, Egypt, Mubarak-era, opinion, recovery
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print
Previous Article Ship to Gaza nearing destination
Next Article Doctors plan to escalate strike
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Ad image
Ad image

Stay Connected

Facebook Like
Twitter Follow
Instagram Follow
Youtube Subscribe

Latest News

India train crash kills at least 207, injures hundreds 
India train crash kills at least 207, injures hundreds 
Politics Breaking News World
Adding flavour of innovation to F&B industry in Africa
Adding flavour of innovation to F&B industry in Africa 
Women
Egypt’s Women on Boards Indicator records 19.7% in 2022 with 3% growth
Egypt’s Women on Boards Indicator records 19.7% in 2022 with 3% growth
Women
Suez Canal Bank signs protocol with Chinese TEDA to support investment in SCZone
Suez Canal Bank signs protocol with Chinese TEDA to support investment in SCZone
Banking
//
Egypt’s only independent daily newspaper in English. Discuss the country’s latest with the paper’s reporters, editors, and other readers.

Quick Link

  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Interviews
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

© 2023 DNE News. All Rights Reserved.

Join Us!

Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest news, podcasts etc..

Zero spam, Unsubscribe at any time.

Removed from reading list

Undo
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?